This past week the Permanent Judicial Commission of the General Assembly issued decisions in three cases related to the movement toward inclusion in our denomination. The rulings are sad for those of us who work for, hope for, and pray for a day when the Presbyterian Church (USA) will demonstrate a love and a justice that is as big and as gracious as God's. These decisions represent a set-back. It appears that these decisions overturn the Authoritative Interpretation passed by the 2006 General Assembly by saying that candidates for ordination may be permitted to depart from an ordination standard related to belief, but not from a standard related to behavior.
Following these decisions, Michael Adee of More Light Presbyterians issued a statement which includes the following reflection on the particular paragraph in the Book of Order which has created so much pain (see More Light's web site for complete statement):
The anti-gay discriminatory ordination policy of G-6.0106b of "fidelity in marriage, chastity in singleness" was added to the Book of Order in 1997. It has brought nothing but pain, division and discrimination in our Church. It has worked against the principles and the realities of peace, unity and purity within our Church. It has driven people out and driven people away from our Church. It is a barrier to people knowing that they are children of God, created in the image of God, unconditionally loved by God and welcome in our Church. It is an impediment to faith and grace. It is a scandal to the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
That All May Freely Serve says of these PJC rulings:
In a decision handed down on February 12, 2008, the highest court in the Presbyterian Church (USA) has ruled that the controversial ordination standard of fidelity in heterosexual marriage or chastity in singleness is a requirement for all persons in ordained office. The ruling perpetuates the mistaken and destructive prejudice that sexual orientation is a matter of behavior and not identity. Further, the ruling puts a wedge between faith and practice, as though to believe one thing and act differently were not the very definition of hypocrisy. The ruling severely damages movement toward greater flexibility, graciousness, and discernment as put forward by the actions of the last General Assembly.
The decision, however, puts stark relief to the necessity for swiftly and finally removing the homophobic and heterosexist policies from the Presbyterian constitution.
The Witherspoon Society maintains a web site that includes links to the PJC decisions and other news covereage and analysis of them.
West Church continues to work for, hope for, and pray for the day when all of God's children are truly welcomed by our denomination.